Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Blog

Why I Studied Panchayati Raj

The research behind my paper on the 73rd Constitutional Amendment, and what surprised me most.

This month my paper, Assessing the Impact of the 73rd Constitutional Amendment on Panchayati Raj: A Two Decade Retrospective, was published in the International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research. People sometimes ask why an MBA student in finance would spend months on village governance.

The question that pulled me in

The 73rd Amendment gave constitutional status to Panchayats and promised them funds, functions and functionaries. It was one of the boldest decentralisation efforts in any democracy. I wanted to know how much of that promise had reached the village.

What I found

Representation improved meaningfully. Reservation for women and for Scheduled Castes and Tribes brought millions of new people into local office.

Money lagged behind. Many Panchayats depend heavily on transfers and scheme funds, with limited own revenue and limited freedom over how to spend.

Capacity is the bottleneck. Without trained staff, records and planning support, responsibilities on paper do not become services on the ground.

Accountability is uneven. Where Gram Sabhas function well and audits are taken seriously, outcomes improve.

Why a finance student cares

Decentralisation is, at its heart, a question of who controls money and who answers for it. The same questions apply inside companies: authority without resources fails, and resources without accountability leak.

How I went about the research

I worked from primary and secondary sources: the constitutional provisions, State Finance Commission reports, central and state scheme guidelines, and published evaluations of Panchayat functioning across states. Rather than treating India as one unit, I compared how different states had devolved funds, functions and functionaries, because the amendment left much of this to state legislatures.

A finding that stayed with me

Representation and power are not the same thing. Reservation brought women and historically excluded communities into office in very large numbers, which is a genuine democratic achievement. But where Panchayats lacked untied funds and staff, elected representatives often had responsibility without the means to act. In some places, real decisions remained with officials or with informal power holders.

What would strengthen local government

Three themes appear repeatedly in the evidence:

  • Predictable, untied funding, so that Panchayats can plan rather than wait for scheme releases.
  • Own revenue, even small, which builds accountability between citizens and their local government.
  • Capacity: trained secretaries, accountants and engineers who can turn plans into works.

Why I keep returning to it

Panchayati Raj is a test of whether a large democracy can trust its smallest units. The answer so far is "partly", and the reasons are mostly about money, capacity and accountability. Those are also the questions I now bring to every organisation I work with.

Read the paper

If you would like the full argument, evidence and references, the paper is available through the IJFMR link on my Writing page. I welcome questions and disagreement.

The full paper is linked on my Writing page.

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...