Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Blog

Advice You Can Audit

Clients deserve to see how a recommendation was reached, not just the recommendation itself.

Consulting has a reputation problem: polished decks, confident conclusions and reasoning nobody can examine. At Limuria we try to work the other way round.

What auditable advice looks like

The question is written down. One sentence agreed with the client before analysis starts.

Sources are named. Every important number points to where it came from.

Assumptions are explicit. Growth rates, costs and probabilities are listed separately from facts, with reasons.

Sensitivities are shown. The client sees which assumptions move the answer and by how much.

The recommendation says what would change it. If prices fall below a level or a regulation changes, the advice changes too.

Why clients value it

A board can challenge advice it can see into. A finance team can update the model when facts change. A decision taken this way can be reviewed honestly later, which is how organisations learn.

What it asks of us

What this looks like in a deliverable

A typical Limuria deliverable has four parts. A one-page answer stating the recommendation and the conditions under which it holds. An assumptions register listing every material assumption, its source and how confident we are. The working analysis, usually a model the client can open, change and rerun. And a sensitivity summary showing which assumptions matter most and the point at which the recommendation would change.

Clients sometimes tell us the assumptions register is the most useful part, because it becomes the agenda for their own discussion.

An example of a changed mind

On one decision, our initial analysis favoured an expansion. The sensitivity work showed that the result depended heavily on one customer renewing a contract. We said so plainly and recommended waiting for the renewal before committing. The client agreed; the renewal came through on different terms and the expansion was resized. Advice that had hidden that dependence would have looked more confident and been worse.

A standard, not a style

Auditable advice is not a presentation style. It is a professional standard: anyone with the right access should be able to check our work and reach the same conclusion from the same evidence, or see exactly where they disagree.

What we ask of clients

Auditable advice works best when clients engage with it. We ask clients to challenge the assumptions register, tell us where their own data disagrees and name the people who will be accountable for acting on the decision. The best engagements feel less like receiving a report and more like building a shared, checkable view of the decision together.

Showing our work means our mistakes are visible. That is the point. Advice that cannot be checked cannot be trusted, and advice that cannot be trusted is expensive however good it sounds.

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...