Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Blog

The Pre-mortem: Checking a Decision Before It Fails

Imagine the decision has already failed. Then ask why. It is the cheapest risk review there is.

At Limuria we use one exercise on almost every important decision: the pre-mortem.

How it works

Before committing, the team imagines it is a year later and the decision has clearly failed. Each person writes down, privately, the most likely reasons. Then the reasons are shared and grouped.

Why it works

It makes dissent safe. People who doubted the plan can now say so without seeming disloyal; they are only answering the exercise.

It surfaces specific risks. "The market might be smaller" becomes "our two largest prospects delay purchases because their budgets are frozen".

It produces actions. Each serious reason becomes a mitigation, an early warning signal or a reason to change the plan.

What we do with the output

  • Risks we can reduce now, with an owner and a date.
  • Signals to watch, with thresholds that trigger a review.
  • Assumptions to test before committing more money.

The connection to checkable decisions

A pre-mortem writes down, in advance, what failure would look like. That makes the decision checkable later: if it goes wrong, we can see whether we anticipated why.

A worked example

A client was deciding whether to enter a new regional market. The plan looked solid. In the pre-mortem, the team wrote down reasons for failure. Three themes emerged: distributors in the region were tied to a competitor through credit arrangements; the price point assumed in the plan was based on urban data; and the team had no one with local relationships.

None of these killed the decision. Instead, the plan changed. The client tested pricing in two towns before full launch, offered distributors better credit terms for the first season, and hired a regional lead before committing major spending. The original timeline slipped by two months; the risk of a costly failure fell sharply.

How to run one well

  • Keep it short: thirty to forty-five minutes is enough.
  • Write individually first, so the loudest voice does not set the agenda.
  • Include people close to execution, not only senior leaders.
  • End with owners and dates for every action, or the exercise becomes a conversation rather than a tool.

When not to use it

A pre-mortem is not needed for small, reversible decisions; trying something and learning is faster. It earns its time on decisions that are expensive, hard to reverse or affect many people: a large investment, a new market, a major hire or a restructuring. The more confident the room feels, the more useful the exercise tends to be, because confidence is exactly when people stop looking for reasons to doubt.

Thirty minutes of imagined failure is cheaper than a year of real failure.

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...