The early signs of a bad loan are usually visible. They are just spread across documents nobody reads together.
During my internship in risk management at Central Bank of India's regional office in Chennai, I reviewed more than twenty-five loan reports. Four accounts stood out as high risk. What struck me was that none of the warning signs was hidden. They were simply in different places.
Signs that sit in separate files
Repayment behaviour. Repeated delays of a few days, or instalments paid just before the account would slip into overdue status, are an early signal long before default.
Financial statements. Rising debtors and inventory with flat sales usually mean cash is getting stuck. Profit can look healthy while the business runs out of money.
Account conduct. Overdraft limits used to the full every month, cheque returns and frequent requests for temporary increases tell a story the annual balance sheet does not.
Collateral and stock statements. Stock values that never change, or that look too round, deserve a second look.
Why they get missed
Each document is reviewed by a different person at a different time. The credit appraisal looks at the balance sheet once a year. Operations sees the account conduct daily. Nobody sees all of it on one page.
What helps
A simple combined view of each borrower, where repayment, statements and account behaviour are read together, catches stress earlier than any single report. Most early-warning systems are, at heart, an effort to put these pieces in one place.
How I approached each file
For each borrower I followed the same order. First, the repayment history over the last twelve months, looking for patterns rather than single events. Second, the latest financial statements, comparing sales growth with growth in receivables and inventory. Third, account conduct: limit utilisation, cheque returns and transfers between related accounts. Last, the collateral and stock statements.
Reading in this order meant that by the time I reached the balance sheet, I already had a hypothesis about where stress might be. The four high-risk accounts I flagged all showed at least two warning signs that reinforced each other, typically delayed instalments together with receivables growing much faster than sales.
What I would build if I ran a branch
If I were designing a monitoring routine for a branch, it would be a one-page view per borrower, refreshed monthly, combining four lines: days past due over twelve months, limit utilisation, growth in sales versus growth in receivables and inventory, and any cheque returns. Each line would carry a simple green, amber or red mark with a clear rule behind it.
Two ambers together would trigger a conversation with the borrower, not a penalty. Most stress is easier to fix early, when the borrower still has options and the bank still has goodwill. The aim is not to catch people out but to start the conversation months earlier than the account statement alone would.
The lesson I took away applies far beyond banking: risk is rarely invisible. It is fragmented.