Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Blog

Why NPAs Are a Story About Incentives

Bad loans are not just bad luck. They follow from how lending decisions are rewarded and checked.

India's banking system went through a long and costly cycle of non-performing assets. It is tempting to explain each bad loan by its own story: a failed project, a downturn, a fraud. The pattern across thousands of loans points to something more structural.

How incentives shape lending

When growth targets reward disbursement but nobody is accountable for loans five years later, lending rises faster than appraisal capacity. When restructuring can postpone recognition of stress, problems are pushed into the future rather than solved.

Why recognition matters

A loan that is in trouble but not recognised as such keeps consuming attention and capital. Clear rules on asset classification, and an insolvency process that lets lenders act, change behaviour on both sides: borrowers know delay is costly, and banks cannot hide problems indefinitely.

What good credit culture looks like

  • Appraisal that tests the borrower's cash flows, not just collateral.
  • Monitoring that treats small delays as information.
  • Recognition of stress early, when options are still available.
  • Accountability that follows a loan through its life, not only at sanction.

A small example from the branch level

Consider a branch manager with a target for new loans this quarter. A borrower applies with good collateral but weak cash flows. Sanctioning the loan helps meet the target now; the risk shows up years later, often after the manager has been transferred. Nothing in this story requires bad intent. The system rewards the wrong moment.

Multiply this across thousands of branches and several years of strong credit growth, and you get a large stock of loans that were reasonable on paper but fragile in reality.

What changed the cycle

Several shifts helped India work through its bad-loan problem: stricter recognition rules that forced banks to classify stress honestly, an insolvency framework that gave creditors a credible path to resolution, recapitalisation of public sector banks and improved monitoring tools. Each changed incentives on the borrower's side, the bank's side or both.

Lessons that generalise

  • Measure outcomes over the full life of a decision, not only at the point of approval.
  • Make recognition of problems safe. People hide problems that will be punished when revealed.
  • Keep a credible exit. Without a way to resolve failures, organisations keep them alive indefinitely.

These apply as much to a company's investment pipeline or a government's project portfolio as to a bank's loan book. Every system that funds things on promises needs a way to learn honestly from the promises that failed.

The lesson for any organisation is broader than banking: if you reward people for starting things and nobody for how they end, you will get a lot of beginnings and a lot of bad endings.

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...